DoctorStrongbad's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Face studies 1]

Good work. Though it would be nice if you just did one face. It's a little confusing to have three faces some in mid air that aren't even related. I know it's a face study but still. I would rather one face per screen/paper.

SimonT responds:

Thanks!
Yeah I understand, I decided to do it like that because if I would do one face per screen I would probably have to do more details and it would take me much more time. So that is the reason why I decided to gathered them together. But yeah I agree with you, if I'll do some more complex study I will definitely put it seperately!:)

[Abandoned]

Interesting idea. The only thing I don't get it what is under the window that seems to be showing an abandon library? Is it supposed to be a door or another window? I would put a gap between the two.

[Talia Concept art]

Nice character. There are a few things that needs to be fixed. The hand looks a bit odd, it looks more like a claw than a hand. The thumb is too far from the rest of the fingers and one leg has a strange point that needs to be smoothed out and both legs look too big compared to the rest of her body. Other than that good job.

BitterBrushAnimation responds:

originally she was holding something in the sketch but i guess i forget to paint that... wasn't really important though, i was just wanting to see if here color scheme was working.. actually both legs have that point so will her chin arms and several other parts of her. i still need to work it out a bit but when i create her model i am gonna try to go for a model that looks like a game model (with those points and creases you see in some lower graphics games.) but is just as detailed and subdivided as a typical model. it is a stylistic choice that i need to iron out some more... probably in 3d space. in short iam a better 3d artist then a painter so i wasn't able to get everything exactly right but its a good starting point. i do appreciate all your helpful feedback! :)

[Breaking Bad Tribute]

Wow, you are the real deal. Congrats!

[Hakuna Matata]

Great job again. The only thing I would say is that Puma's back end looks a little to flat. It would have been better if it was a bit rounder.

[Hail Caesar]

Great job on the color, texture and facial expression. It's not any easy thing to get right.

[Moonlit]

You are very talented.

[Beast]

Great job! I like the glow effect you put around him.

[Yamato Nadeshiko 2]

The top part is good but it looks like halfway through you just gave up and didn't put as much detail.

[girl freestyle]

Very cool 3-d drawing. Would be cool if more people tried 3-d art on here.