DoctorStrongbad's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Tonight We Hunt]

The graphics look great but caused lag while I was waiting for the game to start. You should include a way to change up the controls, your current setup is not user friendly. I am not a fan of fear mechanic, it just seems clunky and not that useful. This game should be better when you complete it. It is just a demo at the moment.

[Sub-Uber-Marine]

What happens when Crazy Taxi and a submarine game gets combined? Well, you get this new concept called Sub-Uber-Marine. This came out very well for being created in 48 hours. The music does a great job of synching up with the gameplay.

Extar responds:

Thanks, I'm glad you appreciated the music, that's always one of my favourite parts of making a game in Pico-8. Just to be clear this is the post-jam version, the version I submitted for the jam made in 48 hours only had the basic gameplay present. :)

[Plug In]

The graphics are okay but could really use some razzle dazzle. The Puzzles can be tough, but fair in this game. If you added some hidden short cuts, that would give the player a chance to explore and be rewarded.

[Heroes Quest]

Graphics are the standard version of pixel art. Controls worked well enough. Nothing really felt new or exciting at all. You should come up with some new ideas and lots more action.

[ART TELEPHONE: Holiday Edition]

Art style is interesting with all of the characters swapping. The animation could have been smoother and transition better. This might work better as a game, that way the player could share in some aspect of helping to create art.

[FIG]

Graphics are pixel art which is the standard for games these days. The entire game feels pretty generic, there is really nothing new or exciting at all. It could use more content and action. Also, I was very confused by your tags of black-anime-characters and black-characters. Was this game made for an event all about black characters? I have played many games with black characters that didn't have to announce it.

[Potion Mission]

The Colors are drab and washed out. They should really be more vibrant. The controls feel off, so that can mess up anybody's experience. If you control the control issues, and brighten up the colors, then this game would improve.

[I Wish I Were the Moon (remastered)]

Graphics look good in this remaster of the original game. That makes it easier to figure out the puzzles. The challenge level was easy for me but could be more difficult for newer players. You did a top-notch job.

[International PixelArt Gallery 2021]

I think this would have made a better movie than a game. Looking at art can be fun, but that is mostly all you do. If you can find a way to include more action and excitement, than players would have more enjoyment.

[T.O.F.U]

This game is influenced by Super Meat Boy, and I Wanna Be The Guy. Graphics are decent enough to tell things apart. However, you have lag issues that really mess up the controls. If you can eliminate all the lag, this game will score much higher.